John Young Architect


The New York Times, January 26, 1989



TV Notes | Jeremy Gerard

'11th Hour' guest says he was censored


Charge of Censorship

A recent guest on Channel 13's new program, "The 11th Hour," was so angered by what he felt was unfair treatment by the show's producer and host that he has taken out several advertisements in The New York Times accusing the station of censorship.

William Shebar, a producer for "The 11th Hour," asked three New York City architects to design an alternative plan for the old Penn Central rail yards on the West Side where Donald Trump proposed to build his Television City. Lebbeus Woods presented detailed drawings of the project. Michael Sorkin wrote a text to explain how the project would be used. And John Young provided the producers with information about the red tape involved in getting such a project built.

Mr. Young said he told Mr. Shebar from the outset that behind the big name architects who design projects such as Television City are the countless anonymous architects and consultants, such as himself, who "deal with the practical sides, the engineering, the politics, the financing -- things the 'visionaries' are not supposed to know about."

"We are the quiet guys you never hear about. who get the things done."

"I said I was going to behave like one of these people, to act out a role. I asked not to have my name mentioned."

To underscore his point, Mr. Young wore a welder's mask at the taping of the program, which was shown on Jan. 10. He didn't say a word during the sometimes contentious eight-minute interview between Robert Lipsyte, the host of the program, and the three colleagues.

Why Mr. Young did not speak on the show is a matter of contention. Mr. Young said he was asked not to speak about political issues because they were "too controversial."

Mr. Young also said he and his colleagues were ridiculed on the program. Mr. Woods said yesterday: "I don't feel there was ridicule. When you bring something of an original nature before the lay public, the response can be, 'Are you for real?' Lipsyte doesn't know anything about architecture. But once we started being serious, engaging him, he got serious."


Back to JYA Bibliography